By Victoria Wellman

|

It is regarded as the fashion capital of the world by many and yet New York has taken a dismal fourth place in a list of America's best cities for shopping.

The news will no doubt come as shock to the thousands of New Yorkers who consider the bustling metropolis to be by far the most sartorially sophisticated city in the country.

But according to a survey conducted by Travel + Leisure magazine, when it comes to a general consumer experience, New Orleans, Santa Fe and Charleston have superior stores.

Not so fashionable now: New York took fourth place in Travel + Leisure's list of best U.S. cities for shopping behind New Orleans, Santa Fe and Charleston

Not so fashionable now: New York took fourth place in Travel + Leisure's list of best U.S. cities for shopping behind New Orleans, Santa Fe and Charleston

The travel publication asked readers to rate 35 U.S. cities with scores between one and five across categories such as nightlife, culture, people, quality of life and shopping.

The shopping category was divided into subcategories of luxury stores, independent boutiques, antiques markets, flea markets and interior design stores and the results subsequently combined for an overall score.

Bottom of the list was Orlando, Salt Lake City and Anchorage, the latter having also earned itself last place in the Best Dressed stakes.

Though New York took the number one spot in the luxury store sub-division followed by Chicago and Los Angeles, it failed to perform when it came to the other types of retail locale.

Despite the perennially trendy downtown area with its plethora of boutiques jam packed with fashionistas, not to mention Brooklyn's hipster contribution to fashion, in the independent category, New York City came a surprising fourth, beaten even by Savannah, Georgia.

When the New York Daily News revealed the results of the poll to nursing student Josh Belier, he exclaimed: 'New Orleans? Really? I’ve never heard anyone say: "Hey, let’s take a trip to New Orleans to go shopping." Everyone comes to New York to shop.'

Top spot: Readers voted New Orleans the best place overall for eager consumers across a variety of sub-divisions such as luxury, boutique and antique shopping

Top spot: Readers voted New Orleans the best place overall for eager consumers across a variety of sub-divisions such as luxury, boutique and antique shopping

Perhaps not any more. At least certainly not for antiques and thrift store finds. Regardless of the popularity and abundance of New York's flea markets and second hand furniture stores, the city didn't even feature in the top ten list for either category.

Again the southern cities fared far better with Houston, Texas rounding out the top ten.

And if all those chic Manhattan interiors magazines led you to believe New York was the place to go for home design think again, it came a poor eighth.

The concluding result was that over all New York only closely beat San Juan, Puerto Rico in a top ten list that featured LA, San Francisco and Philadelphia as well.

Student Anthony Colone, 29, who is about to move to New York from Delaware told the Daily News: 'That must be a mistake. That's just stupid. New York City is the shopping capital of the world.'

AMERICA'S BEST SHOPPING CITIES

1.    New Orleans, Louisiana

2.    Santa Fe, New Mexico

3.    Charleston, South Carolina

4.    New York City, New York

5.    Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

6.    San Juan, Puerto Rico

7.    Los Angeles, California

8.    Savannah, Georgia

9.    San Francisco, California

10.  Providence, Rhode Island

AMERICA'S WORST SHOPPING CITIES

1.    Anchorage, Alaska

2.    Orlando, Florida

3.    Salt Lake City, Utah

4.    Atlanta, Georgia

5.    Dallas/Forth Worth, Texas

6.    Las Vegas, Nevada

7.    Baltimore, Maryland

8.    Phoenix/Scottsdale, Arizona

9.    Washington, D.C.

10.  Memphis, Tennessee

Here's what other readers have said. Why not add your thoughts, or debate this issue live on our message boards.

The comments below have been moderated in advance.

I'm from NYC and I absolutely LOVE shopping here! I wouldn't say it's the best place though as I haven't really shopped anywhere else. I'd love to shop in London one day or Paris or Milan!!

My hometown Is the best. Lmao

what are we talking about here?? are we comparing KMART and shopping malls to Bergdorf Goodman, Barneys, Saks, boutiques uptown and SoHo, jewelry stores and selection of items available???????? There is a Macy's, Bloomingdale's for more affordable options. NYC has what one heart's desire, you just need the $$$$$$$$. Perhaps one should go to Charleston to get one of a kind Carolina Herrera gown or Oscar de La Renta or the latest Lanvin bag!!! HMMMMMMMMMMM!!!! I somehow doubt that.,

Clicked on the rest of the survey, and having been to 48 states and virtually every city on the list, I can confirm these ranking "results" are terrible.

I had never been to New Orleans until a few years before Katrina, & I was amazed at the incredible atmosphere, so different from any other city in the U.S. I loved the mysterious quality of the city & its history & its incredible restaurants. But It was the antique shops which astounded me! We spent three days going through the shops, and found so many wonderful pieces of furniture & paintings which were so much less expensive than any other city. Of course, if you're a Francophile, New Orleans seems to have the best selections. We were also surprised at how inexpensive it was to ship from New Orleans. I was so overwhelmed with sadness when I saw the devastation from Katrina, & wonder if it will ever be what we experienced years ago. I met a charming gentleman in Prague who had wanted to visit New Orleans for years, but had been denied the trip twice during the Communist occupation. He sent us a card when he finally arrived, & said it was a dream come true.

You have to remember, this poll was conducted by Americans. And I hate to say it, but most Americans believe if your town has a Wal-Mart and a Piggly-Wiggly, that's beats out anything on 5th Avenue, NYC or Rodeo Drive, Beverly Hills. Sad but true.

This article is silly. New Orleans is food heaven but shopping? Come on . Unless you need a three voodo stores in row go to new york or vegas.

WHAT??? There is life in the U.S. outside of New York City??? Probably this is only news to New Yorkers. I've also met a dim bulb or too who moved to my area from California who were shocked, SHOCKED, to find that in we do have grocery stores and shopping malls here and that moving cross-country to the South did not mean traveling back in time to the 1700s.

Interesting. I've lived in Baltimore and Scottsdale/Phoenix and found the shopping great in both. You can't tell me that Indianapolis, Detroit and Pittsburg are all better than those two. This is a rubbish survey.

Houston, TX rounded out the top ten??? I don't see Houston on the list. Providence is at number ten.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.